I finally got around to reading a book Trish gave me last year,
Sergeant Nibley, Ph. D., Memoirs of an Unlikely Screaming Eagle written by his son, Alex Nibley. This is definitely a unique book, but I found it very interesting.
First off, it is definitely written in memoir form. There are many snippets directly from interviews that the author did with his dad before he died. There are also many entries that came directly from letter written by Hugh Nibley or journal entries. He also cites a lot of other books (Ambrose a lot, and Frankl too), to give some context. It is a visually appealing book, with interesting sidebars and photographs, and footnotes.
I suppose I should say that it takes a certain type of person to really appreciate this book, in my opinion. First of all, you have to have read some Hugh Nibley. I've read some of his works, and fortunately I read the one that I think is pretty much a pre-requisite to appreciating this book:
Approaching Zion. I don't think it's even enough just to know who Hugh Nibley is. Of course, that limits the audience to Mormons, and only a small percentage of them. The reason I say that is because this book covers the experiences of Hugh Nibley just before, during, and just after World War II. If you read his works he's basically a pacifist (I know, that statement can be argued, but he's very strongly anti-war). That really puts the book in context.
But the interesting part was that he actually enlisted in the Army voluntarily. He didn't ever seem to indicate that what he did was wrong. As the Epilogue mentioned, he was a complex individual with some interesting dichotomies. As I read this book I realized just how much his "criticism" in his later years was really just the result of a pessimistic mind. He pretty much always thought the end was near.
On to the good stuff though. The reason I really enjoyed this book was for the war stories. There were some crazy ones. Nibley was in the 101st Airborne and his job was "Order of Battle." Basically he had to track where the enemy was, where they were going, and in what strength. He was an enlisted man but he scored so high on the IQ test they tried to find someplace where he could use his brain. But he was definitely there on the ground, fighting the Germans.
One funny story happened when he was part of the invasion of Normandy (driving a tank of guys in that he had personally waterproofed). When they in the process of getting into the jeep and driving onto the beach a thought went through his head, "Joseph Smith really messed it up when he put elephants in the Book of Mormon." But then he realized that that was only mentioned in the Jaredite time frame, much earlier than the rest of the Book of Mormon and long enough to make traces of their disappearance scarce.
Another time there was a fellow soldier of his who was Jewish and had escaped from Germany, named David Bernay. He hated Nazis and didn't mind killing them. When they were in France they found a man dressed as a civilian who was German. They thought he was a soldier so the commanding officer told Dave to go shoot him. As they went to a ditch the man started talking to Dave. Right before he was about to shoot him they realized that they were from the same town and this man was the Bernay family servant and he was the one who helped them escape. He was just trying to escape Germany. Obviously they spared his life and gave him a job.
There were some other fascinating stories as well. It really made me interested in WWII. In fact, I read
Man's Search for Meaning afterwards and I'm now reading
Band of Brothers. In closing, perhaps the most interesting thing, is the capacity of Hugh Nibley for understatement. He wasn't totally like a journalist, since he did interject some emotion, but it was minimal. A guy he was having a one on one conversation with pulled a gun out in the middle of it and shot himself in the head. Nibley just says that he got some towels around his head because "head wounds bleed like crazy" and got the medics. Then he mentions going to the funeral and having to write a report. Sometimes he seemed so detached, but it was obvious the war affected him. He was a very interesting man.